“Block print” is used, in shops and on labels, for more than one kind of cloth. Sometimes it means a pattern that was struck by hand with a carved wooden block. Sometimes it means a pattern that looks as if it might have been. Screen printing — through a mesh, by hand or by machine — can copy a block-like motif very convincingly. If you are trying to tell a hand block print from a screen print, it helps to know what each method actually does, and then to look at the cloth rather than at the name on the tag.
This is not a laboratory test, and it is not a way of ranking one workshop against another. It is a set of things you can look for in good light, on a tablecloth, a bag or a length of cotton.
What each method does
In hand block printing, a motif is carved in relief on a wooden block. The block is charged with colour and stamped onto cloth, repeat by repeat. A second colour means a second block, placed by eye onto the first. Pressure, loading and alignment all vary a little from strike to strike.
In screen printing, colour is pushed through a mesh that has been blocked in the non-printing areas. A hand-pulled screen can have life in it, especially on a short table. A machine-driven rotary or flat screen, used for longer runs, is designed to be even. The motif may still have been drawn from a traditional block design. The difference is how the colour met the cloth.
A third method, roller or mill printing, uses engraved cylinders and is the reason a high-street bedsheet can repeat a paisley for twenty metres without a wobble. It is rarely confused with a hand-blocked cloth once you have both in your hands, but photographs can flatten the distinction.
What to look at
Look at the repeat, not at a single pretty flower.
On a hand-blocked length, the join between one strike and the next is the giveaway. An outline may overlap slightly, or leave a hairline gap. A petal that should sit in the same place in every repeat may sit a millimetre up or down. The density of colour can change at the edge of a block, where the wood met the cloth a little more, or a little less, firmly. On a pale ground you can sometimes see a faint whisper of the block’s edge.
On a screen print, especially a commercial one, the repeat is usually steadier. Colour sits in a flatter, more even film. Joins, if you can find them at all, tend to be hidden in the design or are mechanically regular. A very sharp, identical motif across a wide cloth is more typical of a screen or a roller than of a wooden block.
None of these signs is absolute. A highly skilled printer can lay blocks with great evenness. A hand-pulled screen can be uneven. Looking at several repeats, rather than one, is more useful than looking for a single “gotcha.”
What not to rely on
Do not rely on the word “handmade” alone, or on a rustic-looking photograph. Do not rely on price: both methods can be cheap or expensive, depending on the cloth, the colour and the labour. Do not rely on a slightly crooked hem, which is a sewing matter, not a printing one.
We also will not offer a home “water test,” a bleach test, or a magnifying-glass rule that claims to settle the question in one look. Those shortcuts are often shared online, and they can damage a piece without proving anything.
If a seller is being careful, they will usually say whether the cloth was hand-blocked, hand-screened or mill-printed, and where the work was done. It is reasonable to ask. It is also reasonable for a workshop to say, honestly, that a design is “block-inspired” if the printing itself was done through a screen.
How we use the words
When we describe our family-name tablecloth as hand block-printed, we mean that the sage floral trellis is printed in Jaipur with carved wooden blocks, then finished with an embroidered name or initials. The same is true of the printed cotton in the quilted wash bag, tote, pyjamas and hot water bottle cover. We do not call a machine-printed cloth a block print, and we do not attach a Sanganer or Bagru village name to work that was printed in Jaipur.
A little movement in those repeats is something we expect you to see. If you would like the background to the method, the Jaipur guide to hand block printing covers the tools and the two neighbouring traditions in more depth. For keeping the colour kindly once the cloth is in the house, see how to care for block-print cotton.